
When I saw the headline Simon Cowell Confronts Brick-Wielding Intruder in London Home, I assumed Jessie J had drastically misinterpreted the scale of the ‘battle’ between Britain’s Got Talent and The Voice UK.
As it turns out, it wasn’t the aggressively-fringed pop starlet but merely an “overzealous fan”. To someone as used to facing down lunatics as Cowell, I doubt this intrusion barely registered.
Instead, he was probably wondering how his Saturday evening light entertainment juggernaut was bested in the ratings by a BBC show that spurned a crucial plank of his TV Midas touch formula.
To him, spending a few hours mocking a procession of attention-seeking wannabes as they desperately try to outdo each other in their efforts to “stand out” (ie look mental), is the raison d’etre of the modern talent show.
That The Voice has drawn first blood despite the fact the judges don’t get to see the contestants until they have passed judgement, must have galled him mightily.
To add insult to near injury, not only was BGT beaten in the head-to-head ratings battle, The Voice was much more popular online than its established ITV1 rival.
TV-themed social media hub Tellybug claimed The Voice was the subject of 60% more searches on Yahoo! than BGT, and Twitter users were also talking more about the BBC programme, with 130,351 tweets about The Voice during its transmission. The equivalent figure for Britain’s Got Talent was 63,639 tweets.
While tweets about The Voice dropped markedly once Britain’s Got Talent began on ITV1, the BBC1 singing show was still the more talked-about while the programmes were overlapping: between 8pm and 8.20pm, The Voice was the subject of 37,136 posts on the social network, compared to BGT’s 20,079.
Will Cowell’s ire last? It’s doubtful. His success is fuelled by coverage and, as showbiz PR legend Mark Borkowski pointed out, the publicity battle was clearly dominated by one man alone.
“You can’t manufacture, train or interview for a showbiz force like Cowell,” wrote Mark and he’s right. Even without the break-in, the coverage of The Voice would have hinged around Cowell anyway.
Until the Beeb grows “publicity balls” (Borkowski again), Cowell’s opinion on Saturday night TV will carry infinitely more weight than anyone at the BBC.